July 29, 2002. The American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance (AHGA) hailed
two separate actions that will benefit both homeowners and the economy.
The U.S. House of Representatives late last Friday narrowly approved a
bill that would give the President broad powers to negotiate new trade
agreements while simultaneously extending more benefits to Americans hurt
by foreign competition. And, in an unrelated action on the same day, the
World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled that countervailing duties imposed by
the U.S. Commerce Department on imports of Canadian softwood lumber should
be rescinded.
“Both of these actions will help homeowners”, said AHGA President Beth
Hahn. “Free trade is in the interest of homeowners and other consumers
worldwide because it lowers the cost of the goods and services we must all
buy. The trade legislation also provides substantial new benefits, costing
up to $12 billion over 10 years, to workers who are dislocated as a result
of foreign competition. Those needed benefits will enable most displaced
workers to retrain for new jobs in a changing world economy.”
The Trade Adjustment Assistance part of the bill provides a 65 percent
tax credit to help workers dislocated by trade to buy health insurance. It
also extends existing financial and training benefits for those affected
by trade to secondary workers such as suppliers to plants hit by foreign
competition. The task of approving the "fast track,” or trade
promotion, authority and worker benefits now falls on the Senate. “We
hope that they will pass the bill before they leave for the August recess”
said Ms. Hahn.
Even better news for homeowners is the July 26 preliminary ruling by
the World Trade Organization (WTO) that countervailing duties imposed by
the U.S. Commerce Department on imports of Canadian softwood lumber should
be rescinded.
"It is unfortunate that pressure from timber interests lead to the
Commerce Department’s protectionist decision to impose a tax on home
buyers who are now paying duties averaging 27.2 percent on Canadian
lumber," said the AHGA President. "Adding between $1,000 and
$2000 to the cost of new U.S. homes in these perilous economic times is
bad policy. We are glad that the cases before the WTO and the North
American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) will result in the total or partial
repeal of the tariffs."
In a letter to President Bush (attached) AHGA thanked the President for
his support of free trade and congratulated him on his victory on the
trade legislation. In the same letter AHGA urged the President to stand
down from further efforts to defend the new home tax. “Now that the WTO
has ruled, there is no further reason for the Administration to defend
this anticompetitive tax that will only drive our country into a deeper
recession” according to the AHGA President. “Better to be consistent
with the principles of free trade the President has long espoused and let
this terrible tax die”, she added.
The American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance (AHGA) is a national
bipartisan advocacy organization representing the nation’s 70 million
homeowners. AHGA believes that policies that encourage and protect home
ownership are in our national best interest. Those policies encourage and
sustain the maintenance of a strong and broad middle class, build a sense
of community and responsibility, and facilitate investment in homes, which
are the largest, most universal savings/equity-building vehicle for most
Americans. AHGA’s positions and more information about the organization
are available at www.AmericanHomeowners.org. The American Homeowners
Foundation’s section of the website also contains free educational
materials to help homeowners and future homeowners buy, sell, remodel, and
finance their homes.
July 29, 2002
The Honorable George W. Bush
President
United States of America
1600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW
Washington, DC 20500
Dear Mr. President:
On behalf of the nation’s 70 million homeowners we write to thank you
for your support of free trade, and to congratulate you on the House
passage of legislation both enacting “fast track” negotiating
authority and extending more benefits to Americans hurt by foreign
competition. We also ask you to support America’s homeowners in another
victory for free trade that also occurred last Friday.
Homeowners and other consumers in the U.S. and other countries benefit
from free trade through overall savings in the total cost of goods and
services. In a world economy that changes with increasing speed it is also
appropriate to address the inevitable dislocations that result with a
substantial trade adjustment package that provides assistance while
dislocated U.S. workers re-skill. This is a far more preferable approach
than erecting protectionist barriers that cost all consumers and hurt far
more people than they protect.
We pledge our support for this important legislation and join you in
urging the U.S. Senate to pass this measure before it adjourns for the
August recess.
We hope you will join us in celebrating another victory for free trade.
Also on Friday the World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled that
countervailing duties imposed by the U.S. Commerce Department on imports
of Canadian softwood lumber should be rescinded. This tax on new U.S.
homes is adding between $1,000 and $2,000 to the average cost of a new
U.S. home. With real estate one of the few remaining healthy spots in our
otherwise challenged economy, the importance of repealing this
protectionist tariff cannot be overstated.
The WTO’s decision confirms our belief that your administration has
been provided inaccurate information on this important issue. It presents
a timely opportunity for you to reconsider the facts on this issue.
When you consider the WTO’s decision and other facts we believe that
you will agree that it is now time to stand down from further support of
the new home tax. With the likely enactment of a substantial trade
adjustment package to help any future displaced U.S. timber industry
workers, there is even less reason to continue to support the new home
tax. Our economy doesn’t need this tax right now. What it needs is an
economic boost, not a subsidy for the small U.S. timber industry.
Thank you for your consideration. We hope that we may soon write to
congratulate you on the final passage of the “fast track” bill as well
your decision to support the nation’s homeowners by withdrawing support
of the new home tax.
Sincerely,
Beth Hahn
President