July 2007

Home

Home Base
A publication of the American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance and the American Homeowners Foundation   www.americanhomeowners.org

ahf ahga

July 2007      


In this issue of Home Base:

National Affordable Housing Trust Fund Introduced
Good News for Homeowners on the Tech Front
Annual declines continue in Home-price index
Energy Bill Progresses
Remodeling Revisited
Potpourri


National Affordable Housing Trust Fund Introduced

The first major housing program proposal in decades has been introduced. It may help stabilize home values.

Senior House Democrats and Republicans in late June introduced bipartisan legislation intended to produce, rehabilitate and preserve 1.5 million housing units over the next 10 years. According to a June, 2007 survey released by mortgage lender Wells Fargo, 80% of Americans support legislation that would encourage home ownership. The new bill will initially allocate between $800 million and $1 billion annually to states and local communities, without increasing government spending or the federal deficit. The National Affordable Housing Trust Fund will instead be funded by proceeds from the recently passed Government Sponsored Enterprises' (GSE) Affordable Housing Fund (H.R. 1427), from savings from Federal Housing Administration reforms contained in H.R. 1852, the Expanding Americans Home Ownership Act, and from any other funding sources that may be subsequently identified.  Under the Trust Fund bill, 60% of the funds will be allocated directly to local communities, with the remainder to be granted to states, insular areas, and Indian Tribes.  The Trust Fund will be the largest expansion in federal housing programs in decades. 


The fund can be used to provide down payment and closing cost assistance for first-time home buyers and to build, rehabilitate, and preserve affordable rental housing. Expanding the number of first time buyers will also indirectly increase the number of move-up buyers for higher-priced homes, and this will help stabilize U.S. home prices. Understandably, the bill is targeted to those families most in need - provisions require that 100% of the funds go for the benefit of low income families and that three quarters of all funds go to extremely low income families.   

States and localities are required to make Trust Fund grants to qualified entities (which include for profits, nonprofits, agencies, and faith-based organizations) that propose affordable housing projects designed to meet the highest priority housing needs in their jurisdictions. Funds will be awarded under funding competition rules that includes matching requirements from state, local, or locally controlled other federal funds, and it includes provisions to reallocate funds from any grantee that does not follow the rules or does not distribute the funds in a timely manner.  The bill also includes a number of provisions to ensure that the funds are used for housing and are not misused, including:   

  • A strict prohibition against any funds being used for a recipient's political activities, advocacy, lobbying, counseling, travel, preparation or advice on tax returns, or other unrelated expenses;
  • Limits set by HUD on how much grantees can spend on administrative costs;
  • A requirement by HUD to establish program regulations, authority for HUD to audit each grantee's compliance, a requirement that each grantee develop systems to ensure program compliance, and require annual state fund use reports, and;
  • Authority of HUD to impose penalties on grantees that do not comply with requirements, including requiring grantees to reimburse misused funds.

The American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance supports the National Affordable Housing Trust Fund because we believe that it is balanced and fiscally responsible. Hearings on National Affordable Housing Trust Fund will be held in July.

AHGA also supports the Expanding American Homeownership Act, which would modernize the Federal Housing Administration loan program to make FHA loans more available to American homeowners, and other pending measures that will contribute to both the expansion of home ownership and stabilization of home values.

top


Good News for Homeowners on the Tech Front

Several recent developments related to the application of technology to important policy goals of the American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance offer good news for homeowners.

On the healthcare front a comprehensive and bipartisan bill introduced in June by Senators Edward Kennedy (D-MA.), Mike Enzi (R-WY.), Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-NY) and Orrin Hatch (R-UT) joins a growing number of critically important bills introduced to fundamentally improve healthcare. The legislation applies technology applications to reduce healthcare costs and would:

• Provide federal financial incentives to practitioners of care to facilitate the adoption of health IT, and for communities, states, and other entities to plan health IT components and develop health information exchanges.
• Encourage patient education that would encourage the use of electronic health records and provider quality information.
• Establish federal leadership of a federal-state process to resolve policy issues central to a secure and safe health care system, like privacy and professional licensure.
• Create a statutory federal responsibility to lead a public-private process to establish standards for health system interoperability, product certification, and quality measures, and an accelerated process for standards improvement.

The legislation would help drive down health care costs by significantly reducing 30 percent of all healthcare spending (about $300 billion annually) that is still going toward duplicative paperwork, redundant tests, over-medication, inappropriate care or avoidable hospitalizations and emergency room visits.  It could also save nearly 100,000 lives annually.

Another significant benefit would be that the legislation will help promote advanced medical technology that will soon enable many homeowners with chronic medical conditions to remain in their homes while their health can be monitored remotely 24/7 though the use of wearable wireless medical monitoring devises.

The Internet has many other important applications for homeowners in addition to healthcare. For that reason the results of a study released in late June by the Federal Trade Commission were very encouraging. The study found that Internet services competition is alive and well. There is therefore no immediate need for new federal rules safeguarding the flow and speed of information on the Internet because there's no current evidence of market failure. According to the report, approved by all five FTC commissioners, existing antitrust laws and FTC oversight responsibility and resources are sufficient to assure that consumers need not fear that their unfettered access to Internet content providers will be threatened by those who provide them Internet access. "To date we are unaware of any significant market failure or demonstrated consumer harm from conduct by broadband providers," said FTC Chairman Deborah Platt Majoras. "Policy makers should be wary of enacting regulation solely to prevent prospective harm to consumer welfare, particularly given indeterminate effects on such welfare of potential conduct by broadband providers." she added.

The Alliance believes that the FTC’s analysis is credible because of the Commission’s excellent track record in enforcing competition in the Internet arena. While competition between Internet service providers is thriving, there has been substantial abuse by some Internet content providers. Of particular benefit to homeowners has been the FTC’s aggressive pursuit of many real estate industry multiple listing service’s (MLS’s) discrimination against homeowners who use discount real estate brokers. The MLS’s are the dominant source of Internet listings of U.S. homes for sale, which they distribute through the websites of thousands of real estate brokers across the country. Today 80% of home buyers use the Internet in their home search process. Until recently many of the MLSs prevented or made it very difficult for potential buyers to see Internet listings of home sellers who use discount brokers. Under threat of lawsuits by the FTC all but one MLS have eliminated barriers that prevent potential buyers from seeing Internet listings of home sellers who use discount brokers.

The FTC is pursuing a federal antitrust lawsuit against the remaining MLS, Realcomp II, over its restrictions on consumers Internet access to property listings of home sellers who use discount brokers. One of the injured discount real estate brokers also filed an antitrust lawsuit against Realcomp II in June, alleging that the MLS sought to block the company's access to MLS data "as part of their efforts to destroy (its) innovative business model and to thwart competition.” The discount broker offered a cash rebate of up to 1 percent of the sale price to buyers who used the company's services, and for sellers the company typically offered to list a property for a total commission of 4.5 percent of the home's selling price, which is lower than the typical 6% commission rate. AHGA believes that addressing these kinds of existing abuses by Internet vendors, which are costing homeowners millions of dollars every year, continues to be the highest and best use of FTC’s limited resources.

The Department of Justice (DoJ) is also involved. DoJ's Antitrust Division is currently suing the National Association of Realtors to overturn association regulations that restrict the dissemination if homeowner's listings on the Internet.

AHGA also expressed these views regarding Internet abuses by real estate brokers to the Federal Trade Commission’s sister agency, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). In AHGA’s June 15 response to the FCC’s Notice of Inquiry on the status of the Internet we further noted importance of the Internet to many other activities of American homeowners. There is a fast growing U.S. trend towards teleworking – both telecommuting from home and rapid growth in the creation of home-based technology-centric small businesses. Homeowners and other consumers are also increasingly using the Internet for everything from paying bills to ordering products and services. The Internet is an increasingly important tool in the K-college educational process. Developments in telemedicine will help reduce our nation’s spiraling medical costs. Many of these trends are also helping to take many vehicles off the road, lessening pressure on the nation’s transportation infrastructure and reducing vehicular pollution and global warming.

AHGA strongly supported the FCC’s 2005 Internet Policy Statement containing the FCC’s commitment to protect consumers’ access to the lawful online content of their choice, and to foster the creation, adoption and use of Internet broadband content, applications, and services. The principles contained in that policy statement concisely define the essence of a free, open, and neutral Internet. Aggressively enforcing these principles is the most important role that the FCC can play in maintaining the vitality and potential of the Internet.

AHGA urged the FCC to support the efforts of federal competition agencies to suppress ongoing and blatant anticompetitive practices of certain Internet content providers, and take steps to help address the looming capacity challenge being created by the exponential increase in Internet bandwidth demand. While the FTC is currently taking the lead against abuses by Internet content providers, it is important that the FCC, to the extent that it is empowered, also fully investigate and aggressively enforce our antitrust and competition laws to stop companies who are currently clearly using their market power to limit competition on the Internet.

The exponential increase in bandwidth demand is becoming a growing barrier to broadband speed and affordability. By 2010, twenty typical households will generate as much traffic as the entire internet moved in 1995, according to John Chambers, CEO of Cisco. The many new data-rich content sources and applications are greatly benefiting homeowners and other consumers, but they clearly point to the urgent need for new national policies to encourage the expanded capacity, wider availability, and affordability of broadband. Although the rapid expansion of broadband adoption clearly demonstrates that it continues to provide an increasingly valuable and affordable service to many consumers, there are clearly segments of the population for whom broadband affordability and/or access remains a serious challenge. For these reasons policies should be implemented to help assure that this very rapid and very beneficial expansion of Internet traffic, which some have termed the “exaflood”, does not become a barrier to the continued rapid expansion of broadband access and to broadband speed and affordability...

Ensuring an Internet that can handle the exponential increase in bandwidth demand is essential for American homeowners, our economy and our environment. AHGA believes that federal tax incentives or subsidies to underserved consumers and/or network platform providers, broadband Internet access service providers, other broadband transmission providers, Internet backbone providers, content and application service providers to increase their infrastructure investments will be key to expanding broadband deployment, speed, and affordability. Support for federal research to expand alternative broadband technologies can contribute to that goal and also increase the number of competitors and allay concerns about market concentration. For its part the FCC should also seek ways within its scope of authority to encourage faster broadband deployment and increase its affordability.

Policymakers should also take aggressive actions to protect privacy, reduce spam, and stave off viruses, worms, or other “hack attacks” that injure consumers, consume bandwidth, and/or disrupt networks and interfere with emergency response. These actions should include stronger criminal penalties and increased enforcement as well encouraging the development of technologies that offer similar protections.

top


Annual Declines Continue in the Home-price Index

Although some markets are doing reasonably well, home prices in many parts of the country continue to drop.

The monthly Standard & Poor's/Case-Shiller 20-City Composite index measured the 17th consecutive month of annual decline in April and has been in negative territory since January 2007. The index monitors annual price changes of single family homes.

Fourteen of twenty cities registered price declines in April, according to the report. In many cases unique factors affected to the status of home values. For example in Detroit, where home values were down 9.3%, the continuing decline of the U.S. auto industry has no doubt contributed significantly to the decline. However there’s no such obvious factor in other cases, such as San Diego, where home prices have declined by 6.7% and Washington, D.C., down by 5.7%. The latter two were among the strongest beneficiaries in the run-up of home prices, so it may be that those declines are more a realignment with the slower, but still impressive, home appreciation rates that occurred over most of the rest of the country over the first half of this decade.

Despite the decline in home values in most areas, homes appreciated substantially in others. In Portland, Oregon home prices increased an impressive 6.4% over the last year. Seattle and Charlotte, North Carolina did even better, appreciating at 7% and 9.6 respectively. That appreciation wasn’t typical for other cities in their regions – “no region is immune to the weakening price returns," according to Robert J. Shiller, chief economist at MacroMarkets LLC.

More declines are expected in the future. David Shulman of the Anderson Forecast at the University of California, Los Angeles recently characterized the outlook as “not a recession, but it is certainly close," In an interview with Inman News, Shuman said he anticipated a 10 percent price decline in home prices "that will likely extend into 2009."

According to PMI Mortgage Insurance Co.'s latest Market Risk Index, the 15 largest metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs) have a 50% or greater chance of a price decline, and 7 have a 10% chance of price declines in the next two years.

The fifteen MSAs with a greater than 50% chance of price declines, in descending order of risk, were:

  • Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario, CA
  • Phoenix-Mesa-Scottsdale, AZ
  • Las Vegas-Paradise, NV
  • West Palm Beach-Boca Raton-Boynton Beach, FL
  • Los Angeles-Long Beach-Glendale, CA
  • Santa Ana-Anaheim-Irvine, CA
  • Oakland-Fremont-Hayward, CA.
  • Orlando-Kissimmee, Fla.
  • Sacramento-Arden-Arcade-Roseville, CA
  • San Diego-Carlsbad-San Marcos, CA
  • Ft. Lauderdale-Pompano Beach-Deerfield Beach, Fl
  • Miami-Miami Beach-Kendall, Fl
  • Tampa-St.Petersburg-Clearwater, Fl
  • Boston-Quincy, MA
  • Washington D.C.- Arlington-Alexandria, VA

The seven MSAs with less than a 10% chance of price declines, in ascending order of risk, were:

  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Ft. Worth-Arlington, TX
  • Dallas-Plano-Irving, TX
  • Houston-Sugar Land-Baytown, TX
  • Indianapolis-Carmel, IL
  • Columbus, OH
  • Cincinnati-Middletown, OH

There is a high correlation between affordability and risks of declining home values. The higher-risk MSAs had much lower affordability scores than the 7 MSAs with less than a 10 percent chance of a price drop.

Not everyone is depressed by the decline in home values. The next year will be a great time to invest in homes, according to a recent report by Housing Predictor. Record amounts of subprime foreclosures are creating great opportunities to buy a home at below market prices. Investors are aggressively pursuing foreclosures, indicating a level of confidence that further declines in home values won't be significant. Historically real estate investors have made substantial profits buying homes in declining markets according to the Housing Predictor Investment survey.

AHGA urges caution in buying foreclosures. While foreclosure purchases can save buyers a lot of money, they are fraught with risk for unsophisticated home buyers. There is plenty that can go wrong, including undisclosed structural problems and many other problems. Unless you have guidance from an experienced foreclosure expert, and financial reserves in case there turn out to be problems, most homeowners should think twice before getting involved in foreclosures.

top


Energy Bill Progresses

Sweeping energy legislation will help reduce homeowners’ energy costs and help the environment.


On June 22 the U.S. Senate passed a sweeping energy legislation package that would mandate the first major change in the nation's vehicle fuel-efficiency law since 1975. The final vote was 65 to 27. The fuel-efficiency language raises the current 27.5 miles per gallon (mpg) standard for cars and 22.2 mpg standard for SUVs and small trucks, to a new 35 mpg standard by 2020. Gasoline use accounts for about half of the nation's petroleum consumption.

The bill would also require the use of 36 billion gallons of biofuels annually by 2022, define penalties for gas price-gouging, and would expand government powers to investigate price setting by oil companies. Federal grants and loan guarantees would be created to promote research into fuel-efficient vehicles and support projects to capture carbon dioxide from coal-burning power plants and store it underground.

In a related Senate battle, a $32 billion tax package that would have poured money into alternative fuel projects by raising taxes on oil and gas companies was defeated. AHGA has mixed feelings about the package. While it would generate revenue for a worthy cause and would help reduce the pollution caused by oil and gas companies, the new energy taxes would inevitably be passed on to hard-pressed homeowners and other consumers.

Unfortunately neither package included an AHGA-endorsed proposal to create tax incentives and/or subsidies to expand teleworking, including both telecommuting and the creation of home-based businesses. AHGA believes that teleworking eliminates a lot of automotive pollution, which is an even better alternative than reducing it. Teleworking incentives would reduce automotive pollution, ease rush-hour congestion, and reduce pressure on our transportation infrastructure. The federal government has set a good example in supporting telecommuting. Today 6.6 percent of the federal workforce - 119, 248 workers – telecommutes, thanks to favorable federal policies. Several forward-thing state and local governments also support employee telecommuting.

On the House side Democratic leaders are having difficulty reaching agreement on a comprehensive national energy package. Speaker Nancy Pelosi had hoped to come up with a comprehensive package by July 4, but Democratic leaders could find consensus in only some areas by then. Noticeably absent from the piecemeal package announced just before the July 4 recess was any increase in automotive mileage standards.

The current Democratic consensus package is the product of 11 House committees and focuses on conservation. Among the most significant components in the House package were those promoting greater energy efficiency in appliances, buildings and electricity grids. It would set new efficiency standards for dishwashers, refrigerators and other appliances; require more energy-efficient lighting; promote E-85 pumps for vehicles that can run on fuel containing 15 percent ethanol, and provide tax incentives to buy hybrid cars with rechargeable batteries. Those components will help reduce both carbon dioxide emissions and electricity bills. About $16 billion in current tax breaks for the energy industry would also be repealed.

The House Democratic leaders may try to first pass the consensus package before tackling the question of mileage standards and other energy provisions that are controversial within the party.

top


Remodeling Revisited

It used to be that that you picked out the flooring, cabinets, countertop and appliances, and then got out of the contractor’s way.

Times have changed. When it comes to remodeling, homeowners are getting more involved, more environmentally conscious, and more aches and pains. Easy Internet access to a huge number of vendors with pictures, prices and specifications on their websites of everything including cabinets, flooring, countertops, sinks and faucets, and just about every other component of a remodeling project, has enabled homeowners to do much of the advance design work before they contact a remodeling contractor. The increasing orientation towards designer components by big box hardware stores like Lowes and Home Depot, as well as the more recent specialization in high end design by Home Depot’s Expo Design Center and others like it, are also leading homeowners to get more involved in the design process.

The process benefits remodeling contractors as well, because estimates are easier and far more accurate when the exact components are known in advance. Homeowners who have already looked at the gamut of choices and taken their time to reach a decision on components before meeting with a contractor are also less likely to change their mind during the construction process. This benefits homeowners, because if they substitute components in mid process they lose much of their control over the final cost. Those changes will not only lead to additional costs if more expensive components are substituted, but there may be restocking fees or other add-ons to the contract price that the homeowner will have only limited latitude to quibble with.   

Some homeowners are saving a lot of money by buying remodeling components on eBay or Craigslist. The selection is quite large - there were 2,738 kitchen faucets on eBay on July 7.  Although the selection in some categories is great, and savings can often be very substantial, homeowners should be cautious about buying remodeling components on the Internet. Some products advertised as new may in fact be returns, and others advertised as in excellent condition may be broken. In addition, returning damaged Internet purchases takes time and costs money, and some vendors don’t provide warranties and/or accept returns. According to Consumer Reports 70% of those they surveyed who used eBay were very satisfied. That’s not too bad, but if you are one of the 30% who might have ended up with what looked like a great bargain on what turned out to be a broken kitchen faucet, you will have a problem if the contractor hooks it up and it starts spraying water all over your kitchen. The best advice is to be careful – don’t buy from Internet vendors who don’t have a lot of transactions and a very high (98-100%) approval rating by their buyers, buy well in advance in case something is wrong, and avoid buying products whose defects may not be apparent until installed (like the aforementioned faucet).

Homeowners are also becoming more environmentally conscious in their remodeling. Reflecting consumer awareness of higher energy prices, more homeowners are often using more than the code-required amount of insulation and super insulated windows in their additions. More are also thinking about the passive solar energy opportunities and the orientation of additions to the sun.

Many homeowners are saving additional money by doing all or part of the remodeling work themselves. Some skills – such as painting or finish carpentry – are especially useful. They come into play at the very end of a project, after the contractor’s work is finished, so there are no scheduling risks. There are other risks however, most particularly risks of injury to homeowners using tools they don’t know how to operate or working past their point of exhaustion. 

Homeowners must take steps to prevent injuries. The first rule is to wear appropriate eyewear and other proper safety gear. Wearing safety glasses when using saws and hammers is essential. Wear work gloves, knee pads and back braces for heavy work, wear earplugs if you are using noisy tools, and a dust mask for any job that generates dust of any kind.

Organize the work space so you are unlikely to trip over power cords or components. Modern cordless power tools will save time because moving cords around isn’t a problem, and they’ll avoid much of the risk of tripping. You can rent tools such as floor sanders, nail guns, tile cutters and jack hammers, but ask for training before you leave the tool rental store if you don’t know how to use them.

Be very careful using ladders – before climbing triple-check to make sure a ladder is firmly planted. Make sure your nail gun has a sequential-trip trigger. The more common contact-trip trigger, which shoots at any time, is responsible for most of the nearly 15,000 nail gun injuries to do it yourself carpenters each year.

Try to use and keep combustible solvents outdoors. Never store a product that produces combustible fumes near a furnace or water heater. Most important, quit before you get tired. The majority of injuries, both the homeowners and professionals, occur near the end of the day, when people start to fatigue but haven’t yet realized it. Being just slightly off in reaction time or alertness can mean a trip to the hospital, which is not worth trying to get the job finished a day or two early.

top


Potpourri

Here’s a potpourri of important news, and useful tips and ideas.

Iggys House offers free multiple listing service (MLS) listings for home sellers in twenty states. Because MLS’s distribute those listings to the websites of their many member real estate brokers, this gets home sellers wide exposure on the Internet, where 80% of today's home buyers are doing searches of homes for sale. Home sellers can post information, pictures and videos of their home in the MLS listings. Iggys House does not charge a commission if the home sells, but home sellers in slow markets should consider offering commissions to buyers agents in their MLS listings in order to help attract prospective buyers. The service was created by BuySide Realty, which offers cash rebates to homebuyers. They are using it to attract customers to use their rebate service, or buy other items that they sell, such as such as yard signs, brochure boxes, lockboxes and real estate forms. The rebate real estate business model is growing rapidly in popularity, and with the slow real estate market and wide selection in many areas, smart home buyers willing to do more of the work themselves are embracing it. The service is available in California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia and Washington. Even though this MLS listing service is free, home sellers should think carefully about trying to sell their homes without a full service agent if they are in a slow market and/or face a moving deadline. In such situations the advantages of a very experienced full service agent with a good track record and good references in your neighborhood may make that a wiser choice. These considerations may also explain in part why real estate commission rates, which had been falling slightly in recent years (though costs in inflation-adjusted dollars have increased due to home appreciation), actually increased by nearly .2% in 2006 last year to just under 5.2 percent.  (Go to www.AmericanHomeowners.org for other free home sellers tips).

How to Be a Dirt-Smart Buyer of Country Property, by Curtis Seltzer ($34.95, Infinity Publishing Company, 2007) is a must read for anybody thinking about buying country property. As growing numbers of homeowners have learned, country property, especially if it’s just outside current urban exurbs, can be both a very enjoyable and profitable experience if held over the long term. However buying country property is also filled with risks for unsophisticated urban and suburban dwellers who think that septic field is the name of their home team’s ballpark. This comprehensive (750 pages!) book covers just about everything you need to know in order to join the growing number of homeowners who are buying recreational and/or investment property in the country. It covers farms, timberlands, and hunting property and second homes, environmental and natural resource issues, negotiating, legal considerations, financing and much, much more. Order your copy at www.bbotw.com, key word “property”. Seltzer, who provides a money-back guarantee on the book, also offers 30 minute initial phone consultations ($62.50), longer open-ended consultations for $125/hour, and other services. Call him at 540-474-3297 or email curtisseltzer@htcnet.org for more information. The book’s content proves he’s worth it, and anyone who lives on Wimer Mountain Road in Bluegrass, VA must know about country property. 

Reduce Global Warming (and your energy bills) with these energy saving tips from Public Services Enterprise Group, an energy services company: Always turn off everything electric you're not using, including lights, TVs, and computers. Use dimmers, timers and motion detectors on indoor and outdoor lighting. Set a programmable thermostat to your seasonal, daily and weekend schedule. Raising your thermostat 5 degrees higher than normal can reduce cooling costs by up to 15% during the summer. Close shades, blinds, and drapes facing the sun to keep the heat out and help fans and air conditioners cool more efficiently. Check the weather-stripping and caulking around doors and windows and replace it if necessary. Eliminate air leaks between window air conditioners and windows with foam insulation or weather-stripping. Keep doors leading to uncooled parts of your home closed, and close air vents in those rooms. Use fans to bring cooler air inside during the night and circulate it during the day. Ceiling fan blades should rotate clockwise during the summer and counterclockwise in the winter - most have a switch on the motor to change rotation direction. Ceiling and other fans provide cost effective cooling and better circulation so you can raise the thermostat and reduce air conditioning costs. Delay activities that generate heat, such as dishwashing and laundry, until evening, and don’t turn appliances on until they have a full load. Replace as many high wattage incandescent bulbs as possible with comparable compact fluorescent bulbs (about 23-watt). Plant shade trees close to the house on the south and west sides. For a copy of the American Homeowners Foundation’s free ten minute self conducted home energy audit, which will help identify more ways to reduce your energy costs, send an email with “free energy audit” in the subject line to AHF@AmericanHomeowners.org.

Beware of incompetent real estate agents. Buying and selling a home is a very complex process, yet the entry standards for becoming a real estate agent in most states is so low (a fraction of the time required to become a beautician, for example) that many inexperienced new agents are incapable of providing the wise advice and valuable service that home buyers and sellers need. That lack of knowledge is part of the reason that there are thousands of consumer lawsuits against real estate brokers and agents every year. A 2007 study by the National Association of Realtors found that commission disputes, property-condition disclosure, and agency issues are the most common source of lawsuits against real estate brokers and agents. Dual agency, a situation where the same broker is trying to simultaneously help both the seller and the buyer negotiate the best deal on the same property, continues to cause problems because of the obvious conflict of interest. Cases involving fraud and deceptive practices, breach of fiduciary duty and breach of contract resulted in the most lawsuit damage awards. Antitrust cases related to a rise in cases over alleged illegal tying agreements are also growing. Since real estate agents and brokers usually don’t get paid unless there is a transaction, there is no way to guarantee that even an extremely experienced and well qualified real estate broker or agent will always put their client’s interest above their own. However an experienced agent is far more likely to know what to do, and by virtue of their staying power, far more likely than a rookie to treat their clients fairly. The industry may wise up one day and substantially increase the entry standards for the profession, which should help improve service quality and reduce lawsuits. Until then the best course of action for home buyers and sellers (especially novices) is never use or work with a real estate agent with less than five years experience, and seek agents with knowledge and experience in your market area who can provide you a list of satisfied references.  (Go to www.AmericanHomeowners.org for other free home buyers and home sellers tips).

A new study by two Northwestern University economists, who chose different methods to sell their homes, revealed that Madison Wisconsin homeowners who sold their homes through traditional full service real estate agents usually got a lower sale price than people who sold their homes without using a real estate agent. Homes sold on FSBOMadison.com, the local for-sale-by-owner Web site, received an average $175,068 while those who used traditional agents and sold through the multiple listing service received an average $173,205 or about $2,000 less. When the agent’s commission was deducted, the sell-it-yourself homeowners netted quite a bit more money. This independent study contradicts another fairly recent study by the National Association of Realtors (NAR) which showed that home sellers who used traditional full service real estate brokers netted 16% more than homeowners who sold their homes without using a full service real estate agent. After the real estate commission, which averages slightly above 5% nationally, homeowners would net almost 11% more according to the NAR study. A NAR representative said that local markets vary so widely that “it wouldn’t be surprising to see a market where there is no difference between an agent-assisted and FSBO price.” Like the NAR study, the economists also found that homes sold by full service real estate brokers sold somewhat faster than houses on the for-sale-by-owner site. The Madison study also did not take into account the value that homeowners might place on the services provided by real estate agents. Nationally, about 13% of home sales were for-sale-by-owner in 2005. A third independent study, by the economists/authors of Freakonomics, concluded that among home sellers using real estate agents, the ones who did best of all were real estate agents selling their own homes. Real estate agents sold their own homes for substantially more than their clients got for equivalent homes for clients. Given the disparity of the conclusions and circumstances between the first two studies, it is difficult to explain the substantial differences in the data. Certainly a study by any industry group that supports its own business model should be carefully scrutinized for potential methodologies and assumptions that tilt the results in the industry’s favor. The independent Madison Wisconsin study, while likely to be more objective, was based on data during a period (1998-2004), when home demand exceeded supply for much of the time, making it much easier for do-it-yourself home sellers to get top dollar. The results of the NAR study, to the extent that they may be more accurate, also raise a very serious note of caution for home buyers. If real estate agents are getting 16% more for their client's home than FSBO sellers, conversely that means home buyers working with those agents are paying 16% more for their homes than they would if they had bought from a FSBO seller. NAR's data suggests that home sellers are benefiting at the expense of home buyers, whose interests in getting the lowest price are apparently largely ignored by traditional real estate agents they work with. If NAR's  data is accurate, buyers will find themselves on a much more equal footing if they try to find an appropriate for-sale-by owner home and negotiate with the home seller directly. Another alternative would be to use an exclusive buyers agent (EBA). EBAs only represent buyers, never sellers, so there is no incentive for them to favor the sellers. To find an EBA in your area go to the National Association of Exclusive Buyers Agents website (www.naeba.org).    

The Consumer Federation of America (CFA) recently released the results of a survey conducted by the Opinion Research Corporation for AARP last June. CFA’s analysis of the survey data reveals that most consumers view the real estate industry and services favorably, but understand them poorly and object to specific practices, according to Stephen Brobeck, CFA executive director.  Only about one-quarter of consumers know that commissions can be negotiated. In fact, about two-fifths think that commissions are set by the industry or its agents while 13% believe commissions are set by state law.  About three-fifths think that a 5-6% commission on a $300,000 home sale is too high.  Over half think that a "dual agent" cannot effectively represent the financial interests of buyers and sellers.  Two-thirds think that there is a potential conflict of interest when seller and buyer agents work for the same company.  And fewer than one-fifth think that buyer access to a local MLS should require signing an exclusive agreement with a broker - over three-fifths believe buyers should get this access simply by paying a fee.  Moreover, recent users of agent services are more critical of these practices than are other consumers.  Yet, all of these practices -- 5-6% commissions, dual agency, in-house sales, and exclusive buyer-agent agreements -- are widespread throughout the industry. CFA reiterated its call on state real estate commissions, which oversee the industry and are typically appointed by the governor, to more energetically inform potential buyers and sellers about these services.  One of the most effective ways would be required distribution by agents at the first contact of a brochure, reviewed by the FTC and consumer groups as well as by industry that referred to a website with more detailed information.

The Internal Revenue Service has ruled that real estate commission rebates to home buyers are not taxable income, but rather represent an adjustment to the purchase price of the home. (PLR 200721013). Those rebates, which can be as much as 2% of the selling price, can amount to $5,000 on a $250,000 home, for example. As real estate brokers who offer cash rebates to home buyers continue to gain in popularity, this is good news. The February 9, 2007 Private Letter Ruling contradicts the position of some state real estate associations, who have been trying to protect high real estate commissions and stop such discounting practices by passing state laws that prohibit real estate commission rebates. Those real estate associations have argued that real estate commission rebates are taxable to home buyers and would encourage tax fraud, because many home buyers are dishonest and would not report the rebates as income when they filed their personal tax returns. The real estate brokers association in Tennessee was successful recently, where Governor Phil Bredesen signed a new law that prohibits real estate agents and brokers from giving home buyers cash rebates. The Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission have expressed their opposition to such anticompetitive laws. According to the FTC and DoJ, rebates "can be powerful tools for price competition between brokers. And by returning money to home buyers, rebates can also benefit home sellers, because buyers will have more to spend on the home as opposed to commission payments." AHGA believes antirebate laws are no more than transparent efforts by full service real estate brokers to protect their traditional 6% commission. It is also an abdication of their fiduciary duty to home buyers and sellers who use their services. The Alliance urges homeowners to express their views on the subject to their governors and state legislators, and to weigh their votes on this issue by their state legislators in deciding who they will vote in the next state election.

Follow these tips and leave your home safe and secure while on vacation:  Don't tell anyone that you are leaving except immediate family and very close friends and/or neighbors.  Stop newspaper and postal mail service until you return.  Ask a neighbor to watch out for any visitors who might be in your yard or knocking on your door.  Lock all the doors, windows and balcony doors. Install a timer so that a lamp or television will come on when it gets dark.  Don't leave lights on 24 hours a day.

There has been an increase in crimes, especially robberies and rapes, associated with unmarked cars posing as police vehicles. Flashing red or blue lights for cars are sold publicly and unfortunately can be purchased by criminals as well as volunteer firefighters and other legitimate emergency personnel. Police are aware of this growing problem, and most will not stop you from continuing to an active public location such as a gas station before pulling over. In the meantime you should indicate that you know they are behind you by turning on your car's flashers or waving. While you continue driving you can also call 911 and/or *77 on your cell. The former can link you to the local police and the latter is a direct link to state trooper information in most states. Both can tell you if you are being followed by a real local policeman or a state trooper, in which case it will be safe to pull over.

top
 



 
Please take the time to contact your legislators and express your views on the policy issues covered in this month’s Home Base. It's easy - you can reach your legislators by email in a couple of mouse clicks, and you can use the content in Home Base and elsewhere on our website to help you develop your message. To look up the phone number, email, and/or postal address of your U.S. Representative or your two U.S. Senators, (or your state representative or state senator) click here. The site can look them up by zip code for you if you don’t recall their names.

Many legislators are also happy to meet personally with their constituents when they are back home on weekends or when Congress is not in session. A personal meeting is a particularly effective way to get their attention and reinforce your message, so please consider also requesting a follow up face-to-face meeting in their home state or home district offices near you when you contact them on policy issues.

Is there a policy issue that is particularly important to you which significantly impacts homeowners or home ownership? Any member may propose a position on a policy issue, so please check the American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance's 2007 Issue Guide to see whether it’s already on our list. If it isn't on the list, we invite you to send us an email and tell us why you think the American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance should be working on it.


 
 
 

Copyright 2007, American Homeowners Foundation and the American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance.